Why do you pick certain Products?

This past weekend I had three wonderful shaves. All three were very different and yet the end results were nearly identical. This got me thinking….Why do we choose certain products? And, do I need so many different products when the end result can be obtained without having so many options? In today’s blog post I am going to look at a couple of factors that determine what hardware/software I use…..


We wet shaving enthusiasts are an odd bunch. While 99%(just a guess) of the male population probably has one razor, one soap or can of goo, one aftershave, and probably don’t even own a brush……those of us who love this hobby have an embarrassment of choices when it comes to the same products. Do we have one cartridge razor? Nope. We have safety razors, single edge razors, injector razors and even straight razors. Not to mention all the various different types of razors in those genres. Safety razors for instance have 3 piece, 2 piece, turn to open, Open comb, slant, and even adjustable versions. Myself I have used all of the different examples of safety razor. In the end once I mastered the technique for each the resulting shaves were all very good. So why do I need more than one? Simple. Variety is the spice of life. I could eat pizza for every meal but that would get pretty boring after a while.

For me I just love the different razors and how they perform. An Open Comb is my choice when I have heavy growth as it can mow down the whiskers smoothly and efficiently. When I’m shaving everyday and have minimal growth a nice mild TTO or 3 piece is my weapon of choice. And when I’m feeling nostalgic or want to use a one of the first razors I ever found in the wild I pick up an adjustable.


The Edwin Jagger DE89L is the first safety razor I ever purchased. And I would buy it again if I started all over again. Immaculate fit and finish, medium-mild aggression, and a fantastic price point for what you get. This beauty is easily my most recommended razor to people who want to start wet shaving, or even those that want to upgrade from a cheaper razor.


The Gillette Fatboy. Highly touted and a must-have for many wet shavers. This adjustable razor is the pinnacle of form and function for vintage adjustable safety razors in my opinion. A solid razor with some great heft that will last multiple lifetimes when cared for properly. Oh and it shaves nice as well with the settings of 1-9 the shave varies from very mild to medium-high aggression.


The Gillette New. Don’t let the teeth scare you. Although open comb razors look ultra aggressive I find they tend to be medium aggressive for the most part. What they are is very efficient. I find they mow down multiple days growth far easier than most safety razors. The Gillette New is a great place to start for open combs as they are readily available and can be had at a great price.

Despite the finished product being similar the way we reach that end point can vary greatly. This to me is my reasoning for having multiple safety razors in my arsenal. Granted I tend to use a couple a lot more than others.

While the razors have a clear reason to why I chose to use them it’s not as clear as to why I use certain soaps or creams. I will try and go over a couple of reasons and hopefully they will make me feel better about having so many options and maybe help you, the reader, in choosing your next soap/cream.

Reason #1 is EASY. THE SCENT. Yep, there isn’t much better than opening a soap/cream tub and getting an intoxicating whiff of one of your favorite scents. In the summertime I love citrus scents above most everything else. From the tart peppery scent of Barrister and man FEROX to the subtle mint/lime combo of Elvado Wild Mint Lime to the straight up Citrus of Cold River Soap Works Select Citrus this genre of scents is where I have the most options. Even my non straight up citrus soaps and creams have citrus notes such as Truefitt & Hill’s 1805 as well as B&M Rhapsody. The citrus soaps definitely get used the majority of shaves during the heat of the spring and summer. Then once it cools down I reach for more robust scents that seem to warm me up like Tabac, PAA Cavendish, Reef Point Espresso and a lot of tobacco based scents and scents with vanilla. One of my newest additions is a soap called Cognac and Cuban cigars which is very robust and warm with a boozy tobacco vibe that I will be using a lot in the coming months.

In the end if your nose likes it you are going to reach for it more than a soap that is just ho-hum to your senses.

Reason #2 PERFORMANCE – A soap or cream that performs well and leaves your face feeling amazing may be the only thing that can trump an amazing scent. Take for instance Haslinger Schafmilch shaving soap. Just an unbelievable performer in every single aspect. Easy to lather, great slickness, great cushion, great glide, and awesome post shave…just about the perfect soap……but its scent is just OK. It smells like really nice hand soap, or a soap from a fancy hotel. Not bad, not amazing, but clean and inoffensive. This soap has been at the top of my list for months and I am sure will remain in my top 5 forever just simply because it performs better than almost every soap there is regardless of price. Another brand I would put in the top performers is Barrister & Mann. When it comes to artisans I feel B&M may be the gold standard. Yes, I am a fanboy, but for good reason. Not only is the performance of these soaps incredible they also have intoxicating scents. Other top performing soaps/creams are Truefitt & HIll, Martin de Candre, CRSW, Strop Shoppe, Tabac, LaToja, in all honesty most of the soaps available do perform well, just some stand above the crowd.

Reason #3 VALUE –  Some wet shavers really are in this hobby to save money, other like myself love a good deal or just want to get a good value for their hard-earned money. It would be easy to go out and buy Martin de Candre if you had the money and be completely happy with the soap. It smells great, performs as well as anything on the market(or better), but its price point is very high at over $70. So when I talk about value I don’t just mean the cheapest soaps you can buy. Im talking good performers with nice scents that don’t cost an arm and a leg. One soap that fits this bill for many(NOT ME) is Arko. It is a shave stick that is under$3(sometimes even less) that is an awesome performer if you can get over the scent. I have found that shave sticks in general are a great value. While they tend to be smaller amounts than soaps they provide great shaves and have a minimal cost so you can often find something you like without having to pay over $15 for a single soap. The LaToja stick would be my stick of choice when it comes to value. It is thrown in my dopp kit for almost every trip I take, and for good reason. It performs in every type of water and smells nice and perfoms great overall. Another choice for great VALUE soaps is RAZOROCK. A tub of Razorock soap is under $10. There are a lot of scent choices and the performance hits WAY above its price point. My pick would be Zi’Peppino which is a green tobacco scent that smells like a nice fresh mens cologne…an outstanding soap and scent. It could be 2 or 3 times more expensive and still a great deal. Stirling Soaps in another wildly popular soap company which hits way above its price point in performance. Tons of scents and performance right up there with some of the best soaps. Personally I love Barbershop year round, and for the summer Margaritas in the Arctic which has a strong hit of menthol. The last soap I would like to mention is a relatively new artisan from right here in Canada called Henri et Victoria. I got these soaps a couple of weeks ago and have used each a few times and I have to say I am really enjoying them. I believe they range in price from $11.99 CAD to $14.99 CAD. For those of you who want the American conversion that’s about $9-$11. Beautiful scents and performance I would say is very similar to Strop Shoppe. Have an eye on this artisan as all of the products he offers are top-notch in my opinion.

Now as for the brushes I don’t really have any rhyme or reason for what I choose. Sure while on vacation I take a synthetic, otherwise it’s usually a spur of the moment choice, or based on what will look good in a shave of the day pic.

Now onto the shaves!!!



Razor : GIllette NEW

Blade : Astra SP

Soap : Henri et Victoria Le Marin

Brush : Semogue Owners Club Boar

Aftershave : ELVADO Ocean Fusion

With each shave I enjoy the Le Marin soap more and more. And the value you get is about as good as it gets. As I said earlier it has awesome performance similar to Strop Shoppe which is priced a good deal higher(average soap is $21 CAD). As for the scent on this soap it is very pleasing yet subtle. I wish the strength was kicked up a notch or two, but more EO and FO would likely increase the cost. I was super Impressed by how well the SOC Boar whipped up the lather with this soap. The Gillette New annihilated the whiskers I had easily and the ASTRA blade was just as smooth as the day before.

The Elvado Ocean Fusion seems to be my go to post shave as of late. A nice rose scent that has added witch hazel tones my face and leaves it feeling fantastic.



Razor : Edwin Jagger DE89L

Blade : Astra SP

Soap : Truefitt & Hill 1805 Cream

Brush : Zenshave/HTGAM LE 2-Band

Frag : Dior Sauvage

This shave was outstanding. My favorite shaving brush whipped up the most luxurious lather with the T&H 1805 cream. The cream is an absolute knockout when it comes to both scent and performance which is why I chose it. As for value it is hard to put a soap/cream that’s $35+ in a great value category. However you get your moneys worth with this cream. If you have the coin it is well worth it.

The razor I chose was the Edwin Jagger DE89L loaded with an Astra SP(which is a great value blade). The razor is a beauty and I love the way it shaves. Whether I use the stock handle or a heavier stainless steel handle I know what Im getting when I use this wonderful razor. Awesome value and aesthetically pleasing. If I had to recommend a razor to someone this would be it without question!

Again I went with Sauvage. Its a nice frag, but not wowing. The more I wear it the less likely I am to buy a bottle of it. Ill stick to Bleu de Chanel for an everyday easy to wear fragrance.



Razor : Gillette Super Adjustable ‘Black Beauty’

Blade : Astra SP

Soap : Proraso Green

Brush : Bluebeards Revenge Corsair – super badger

Pre-shave : Proraso Green

Post-shave: Elvado Wild Mint Lime Balm

With the big game on TV I decided to represent the Eagles by using something green….What better than Proraso Green? Proraso Green is a fantastic soap/cream. Two reasons it is great are the value, and how readily available it is. For about $10 you get a great performer with a menthol hit that feels very invigorating and a scent that just seems familiar. Add to that you can get Proraso at a lot of pharmacies  and/or local supermarkets makes it highly recommended by me. It performs very well and is one of the easiest soaps to lather you will ever find. I used the Bluebeards brush to whip up a fantastic lather. Nice slickness and cushion from a nice creamy lather.

The black beauty is a piece of nostalgia for me. It was the first razor I ever bought in the wild(antique store) and I think it cost me between $3 and $8. SO my first Gillette and my first adjustable as well as my first vintage razor all in one. Not to mention I do prefer it over the Gillette Fatboy as I find the head is a bit lower profile for getting under the nose and it handles a bit better for me. The Astra blade was on its 4th shave and shaved beautifully yet again. I won’t use it again because I think 4 shaves is about my limit for a blade. At the price they can be had it is not worth it to push it longer.

The Proraso Pre-shave really wakes my face up and seems to boost the menthol in the soap even more. A great cooling start to the shave.

The Elvado Wild Mint lime was a perfect end to my green shave. My face feels wonderful despite the frown on my face from the Eagles loss.

Cheers everyone and keep an eye out for an upcoming giveaway on my Youtube Channel!!!




  1. Mickey Oberman · September 21, 2015

    I pick certain products after I have tried a number of them and found one or several that I find are pleasing to use and perform to my expectations. Once I have found what I like I may stop hunting although curiosity might override my budgetary constraints. I may not agree with the experts, but that is the beauty of having such a wide selection available to us wet shavers.

    Soaps, Croaps and Creams:
    Proraso Green. Almost everything from First Canadian Shave Soap Co. MEM from Careline Co. Ltd., Israel. Smolder from The Blades Grim. R.P.Williams Shaving Cream, Toronto. Nivea Men.

    Rolls Razors, Imperial or Viscount. Parker 91R. GEM 1912. My slant does not thrill me.
    Straight Razors: I have 3. It is not them. It is me.

    Rolls Stainless steel for life and then some.
    Personna Red Double edge.
    GEM Blue Star Super Single edge. I am still going to try others.
    Pace Single edge are the very worst blades I have ever tried. They can not shave a human face.
    Stirling Synthetic. The Ultimate. I need search no further.
    Franks Finest Badgers. Excellent at reasonable prices. Beats my only Silvertip.
    Boar, Horsehair. Neither comfortable nor do they perform for me.
    After Shave:
    Aqua Velva Musk.
    I have tried about 2 dozen others. Musk beats them all for my taste.
    Nick Relief Powder by Infa-Lab Inc. Out performs pencils and gels by miles. A little goes a long way.
    Pre shaves, after shaves: I can and do live without.
    Pre shaves, Aftershaves, Gels, Goop, I can and do live without.

    WordPress.com / Gravatar.com credentials can be used.


    • Froogle_Jimmy · September 21, 2015

      Nice choices. First Canadian soaps are really good. Also I gave Smolder to a friend and have always regretted it. That Stirling brush is an awesome deal!!!

      Thanks for sharing


  2. Christian Levesque · September 21, 2015

    I enjoyed reading your post. Thanks for sharing your experience.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Froogle_Jimmy · September 21, 2015

      Thank you so much! I’m glad you liked it. Comments like this make writing these posts totally worth it. I realize this post was a bit long….but I got into it and needed to write!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s